What to do if a contractor doesn’t pay my CIS deductions?

by | Jul 16, 2024 | CIS deductions

The construction industry is a massive sector in the UK economy. You can tell this by walking around Sheffield and seeing the vast building work that has been ongoing in the city centre recently! Recognising this some time ago, HMRC introduced a specific tax scheme for the sector to manage tax compliance for construction workers and contractors.

The Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) plays a pivotal role in managing tax for contractors and subcontractors. But what is the scheme about? Well, it requires contractors to deduct taxes from payments made to subcontractors, ensuring that Income Tax and National Insurance contributions are accounted for throughout the tax year.

In the latest article from our accountant team, we dive into the Construction Industry Scheme, helping you to understand this framework and learn more about what happens if you face the unfortunate situation where a contractor doesn’t pay your CIS deductions.

 

Understanding the Construction Industry Scheme

Let’s delve into who the Construction Industry Scheme applies to. Determining who qualifies as a contractor or subcontractor is the first step. Contractors are required to register if they pay subcontractors for construction work, or, if their expenditure on construction exceeds £3 million within 12 months of their first payment, even if construction isn’t their primary business activity.

Subcontractors, on the other hand, must register if they undertake construction work for a contractor. Those fulfilling both roles must register as both of these to comply with CIS regulations. So you can be both a contractor and a subcontractor, depending on your situation.

The scheme covers contractors who hire subcontractors to perform construction work. Of course, in a diverse sector like construction, this encompasses a wide range of activities, including:

  • Site Preparation: Such as laying foundations and providing access works
  • Construction Work: Including building, demolition, and refurbishment
  • Installation: Of systems for heating, lighting, power, water, and ventilation
  • Civil Engineering: Such as roads, bridges, and other infrastructure

 

Contractors’ responsibilities under the CIS

Let’s cover the contractor’s responsibilities. Contractors are legally required to deduct CIS from subcontractors’ payments unless the subcontractor holds gross payment status. Under CIS, contractors must register with HMRC and then deduct this percentage from subcontractors’ payments based on their registration status; it is important to note that it is the contractor’s responsibility to deduct the right amount of tax from subcontractors. These rates are as follows:

  • Subcontractor Holds ‘Gross Payment Status’: No tax is to be deducted
  • Registered Subcontractors: Deductions are typically 20%
  • Unregistered Subcontractors: Deductions are higher at 30%

These deductions are then reported to HMRC through monthly CIS returns, where contractors detail the payments made to subcontractors and the corresponding deductions.

Failure to comply with these rules can result in HMRC issuing a notice to contractors detailing unpaid CIS amounts and requesting their agreement to these figures. Penalties and interest charges may apply if deductions are not made correctly and on time.

 

What can Subcontractors do if CIS payments have not been deducted?

It is an unfortunate situation to find yourself in. But if you discover that a contractor has not deducted CIS from your payments as required, you can follow these steps:

  1. Document and Communicate: Maintain detailed records of payments received and any communications with the contractor regarding CIS deductions. Contact the contractor as quickly as possible to discuss the issue and seek clarification on payments made.
  2. Review HMRC Notices: If HMRC notifies you of unpaid CIS deductions, carefully review this calculation to ensure accuracy in reflecting your earnings and the contractor’s CIS obligations.
  3. Consider Regulation 9: HMRC may consider exemptions or reductions in CIS liability under Regulation 9, particularly if subcontractors have paid taxes independently.
  4. Appeal HMRC Notices: Subcontractors can appeal HMRC’s decisions regarding CIS deductions. Provide evidence supporting your case to potentially mitigate CIS liability.
  5. Seek Professional Advice: For complex disputes, consider consulting with an accountant with experience in CIS regulations. They can provide guidance on navigating HMRC procedures effectively to keep you tax compliant.

 

What is the conclusion on contractor CIS deductions from our accounting team:

Dealing with a contractor who fails to deduct CIS from your payments can be a challenging situation, but subcontractors have avenues to address this through clear documentation, communication, and importantly, following HMRC regulations. If the contractor fails to deduct the right amount of tax from your subcontractor payments, then they may be faced with a heavy fine.

By engaging with HMRC effectively, you can address unpaid CIS deductions and ensure your compliance with the construction industry’s tax framework.

For further assistance or to explore your specific circumstances, subcontractors can seek advice from the Freedom In Numbers accounting team. If your contractor is struggling to understand or operate CIS, then you can tell them to get in touch with us too, so we can help your contractor stay compliant.

Related Content

Tax Planning

Self Assessment

How do I get money out of my limited company?

Our team is ready to talk to you about your business.
We’d love to help you get back to doing what you love! If you’d like to know how we can help, click the button to get started.